Will the Real Gooey Butter Cake Please Stand Up?

May
27

img_0786img_0786
Gooey Butter Cake, where have you been all my life? A recipe for Gooey Butter Cake was posted in the forum recently and I knew I had to try it as soon as I saw it. GOOEY BUTTER CAKE. Are you serious? I bet God serves stuff like that on the menu in Heaven.

Amazed I’d never heard of Gooey Butter Cake before, I did a little searching around and found that it has been supposedly popularized by Paula Deen. Of course, then I had to check out her recipe.

Which one to bake, which one to bake?

Then I decided I really should bake both of them, so I held a little mini Gooey Butter Cake bake-off in my kitchen. The recipes were quite different from one another. I was intrigued.

Gooey Butter Cake #1

The recipe posted in the forum here comes from a St. Louis Junior League cookbook.

How to make St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake:

Crust
1 cup all-purpose flour
3 tablespoons granulated sugar
1/3 cup butter, softened

Filling
1 1/4 cups granulated sugar
3/4 cup (1 1/2 sticks) butter, softened
1 egg
1 cup all-purpose flour
2/3 cup evaporated milk
1/4 cup light corn syrup
1 teaspoon vanilla
powdered sugar

Preheat oven to 350-degrees. In a mixing bowl, combine the flour and sugar to prepare the crust. Cut in butter until mixture resembles fine crumbs and starts to cling together. Pat into the bottom and sides of a greased 9 x 9 pan.

To prepare the filling, beat the sugar and butter until light and fluffy. Mix in egg until combined. A bit at a time, alternately add the flour and evaporated milk, mixing after each addition. Add corn syrup and vanilla. Mix at medium speed until well blended.

Pour filling into crust-lined pan. Sprinkle with powdered sugar. Bake for 25 to 35 minutes or until cake is nearly set. Do not overcook. Let cool in pan.

Gooey Butter Cake #2

You can see Paula Deen’s original recipe here.

How to make Paula Deen’s Gooey Butter Cake:

Cake
1 18 1/4-ounce package yellow cake mix
1 egg
8 tablespoons butter, melted

Preheat oven to 350-degrees. Combine the cake mix, egg, and butter and mix well with an electric mixer. Pat the mixture into the bottom of a lightly greased 13 by 9-inch baking pan.

Filling
1 8-ounce package cream cheese, softened
2 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
8 tablespoons butter, melted
1 16-ounce box powdered sugar

In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese until smooth. Add the eggs, vanilla, and butter and beat together. Next, add the powdered sugar and mix well. Spread over cake batter and bake for 40 to 50 minutes. Make sure not to over bake as the center should be a little gooey.

I used my homemade yellow cake mix instead of a storebought mix. (Paula Deen!) I don’t know if a storebought mix would have resulted in less cake for the crust, but I found the crust to be far too thick. (I used a 9 x 13 pan, as instructed.)

But even aside from the cake crust, I had other issues with this version. The filling was far too small. Even if the crust had been smaller, the filling itself was still quite thin. And is this really a butter cake? Taking into account that the Paula Deen cake is twice the recipe size of the St. Louis version, there’s more butter in the St. Louis version. The cream cheese overwhelms the Paula Deen version. I’m not saying it didn’t taste good, but I ordered a butter cake and she brought me cream cheese bars.

And completely aside from the point, but what’s with the instructions for 8 tablespoons of butter? Somebody tell Paula that 8 tablespoons is half a cup or one stick.

I know. Now I’m just whalin’ on her.

The real Gooey Butter Cake? It’s version #1, hands-down. It was sweet, buttery, and delicious, and everything I expected a Gooey Butter Cake to be!

Okay, now who wants some butter cake? I have extra….

The Farmhouse Table Index–See All My Recipes
Printer-Friendly

More posts you might enjoy:

24 Responses
RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack this post

5-27
4:02
am

I’ll have some!

It would go great with my coffee this morning.

Wendy - Reply
5-27
4:22
am

Oh, I am so glad you liked it! Isn’t it just amazing? I sometimes wonder if Miss Paula has ever eaten real GBC?

Now, you need to remember this. It is fantastic the first day! It is good the second (or so I have heard) if there happen to be leftovers. But, get it out of there by day three.

Kathryn - Reply
5-27
4:36
am

Anything with 3/4 of a cup of butter has to be good. I think I’ll make this one for our families last day of school celebration.

Heidi533 - Reply
5-27
4:54
am

Ooooo, you made it!! It looked so darned good when it was posted in the forum, it looks even better now, especially when it beats Paula Deen!

Congrats Morgan on the NJHS! Looking very smart in those glasses!

CindyP - Reply
5-27
4:55
am

Too far for me to drive this morning and I’m sure it would send my blood sugar sky high. Do you think a serving would butter up Mean Rooster?

Sheila Z - Reply
5-27
6:10
am

Suzanne you are my hero! I was going to have to have a bake off at my house to see which was better, now I’ll just make the first one and be done with it. Otherwise, I’d have to make both! I confess that I have made Paula’s many times but when I saw the other St. Louis Version on the the forum, I thought Uh-oh! It sounded wonderful!

KentuckyFarmGirl - Reply
5-27
6:21
am

I have made St Louis Gooey Butter Cake many times and eaten it even more times! I’m from St Louis and I have never heard of the recipe you have called ‘St Louis Gooey Butter Cake’. The one I have used, and that my friends up there use, is the Paula Deen version. It’s easy and oh, darlin!!!….it’s fantastic!
I highly suggest making two at a time cause they don’t last very long!

Carol Langille - Reply
- 5-27
  6:25
  am
  
  I didn’t name it that, LOL. It’s from a St. Louis cookbook which calls it St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake. If you follow the link in the post to the forum post about it, there’s a link there to the cookbook and more information about where the recipe came from.
  
  The Paula Deen recipe is actually pretty good, it’s just cream cheese bars, that’s all.
  
  Suzanne McMinn - Reply
5-27
6:25
am

Well, I am not willing to waste good ingredients. I will just take your word for it and stick with the St Louis version. Sorry Paula Deen–ya messed one up.
Maybe for Dessert/breakfast on a different weekend–we are going CAMPING this weekend! Yahoo

monica - Reply
5-27
6:32
am

I agree with Carol. I’m also from the St. Louis area. While I don’t have my recipe in front on me, I know I always use yellow cake mix, cream cheese and tons of powdered sugar.

I’ll have to try Suzanne’s gooey butter cake #1 sometime.

I’ve also recently run into a recipe for chess cake, which also seems very similar.

Rock on, gooey butter cake!!!

Kris7
Working hard at http://www.sccworlds.com

kris7 - Reply
5-27
6:47
am

You are making being good on Weight Wachers very difficult!

Bev - Reply
5-27
6:48
am

watchers….should proof before posting…LOL

Bev - Reply
5-27
6:48
am

That “Paula Dean” version is called a “Chess Chewie” and my granny’s been making them forever. They are NOT cake, were never meant to be thought of as cakes, they’re more along the lines of ultra-rich anti-brownies, and while darn tasty, they are richer than ell and are not meant to be eaten by the faint of heart, hurt of tooth, or craver of cake. It’s almost fudge! However, wrap 1-2″ squares individually in plastic wrap and it keeps/travels well.

Jenna - Reply
5-27
6:53
am

Born and raised in St. Louis, Gooey Butter has always been a household favorite! It’s always funny with other people “discover” it and wonder how they never knew about it! LOL Isn’t it funny how some foods stay so regional?

The Gooey Butter Cake originated in the early 1940’s as a mistake by a St. Louis Baker. Today it’s found in most bakeries and grocery stores in the St. Louis area.

~TidyMom

TidyMom - Reply
5-27
7:00
am

Gotta go try it! My sweet toothed husband needs it today! I’ll also try #1, sounds better.

Lynda Dunham-Watkins - Reply
5-27
7:17
am

I’m afraid I never heard of Gooey Butter Cake, which is a good thing since I don’t bake. I’d be craving it all day if I had a clue!

So I’ll just congratulate Morgan – farm girls rock!!!

Nancy in Atlanta - Reply
5-27
9:13
am

I have banana bread in the oven. Fingers crossed!!! I will take a piece. Just send it straight to RI. Looks sooooo good. Have you seen Paula lately. I thinks she had her neck pulled – her double chin disappeard.

trish - Reply
5-27
2:23
pm

I WOULD TAKE SUZANNE”S RECIPES ANY DAY OVER THOSE TV “COOKS”–WE KNOW WHERE THE GOOD STUFF IS AND WHO IS A REAL COOK!

JOJO - Reply
5-27
3:59
pm

I just had a piece of gooey butter cake at an ice cream social at church a few days ago. I said the same thing you did, “Where have you been all my life”. My friend Bonnie made it and she is a huge Paula Deen fan so she probably made Paula’s version. Yummm!

Sarah in Sanford - Reply
5-27
4:25
pm

I had gooey butter cake in the 70’s. My ex SIL’s mother made it..it was good!

I love TEXAS SHEET CAKE – YUM!!!!! Chocolate (milk chocolate!),a tad of cinnamon (or not) and toasted pecans on top. HEAVEN

Donna - Reply
5-27
5:20
pm

Have I ever told you that you’re my hero? Because you’re my hero. Some days when it’s an awful day at work I tell myself, “When I grow up, I want to be Suzan.” Hope you’re having a great day on the farm.

LisaAJB - Reply
- 5-28
  9:17
  am
  
  Or “Suzanne”, even?
  
  (Lisa’s my baby sister. I’m allowed to tease her.)
  
  Ulrike - Reply
5-27
6:20
pm

Oh my word, girl. Even though I share the same home state as Miss Paula, after reading your blog for a year or more now, I would most definitely make one of your recipes over hers anytime. Yours are tried and true! Thanks for being our personal taste kitchen. Making this cake is next on my to-do list!Destiny

Destiny D - Reply
5-29
1:06
am

I have to say, your “real” version looks amazing and I can’t wait to try it! I have tried Paula’s version, but not with cream cheese. My family really likes pumpkin gooey butter cakes, which is a great combo. My first time eating gooey butter cake was at the Lady and Sons and it was a sweet potato gooey butter cake, which was also fabulous. I can only imagine a pumpkin or sweet potato version of your St. Louis Gooey Butter cake…mmmmmmmm!!!

Jenny S. - Reply